PUNTERS
Overall Rating
0 = Bus Driver
1.4 = Special Teams
2.4 = Back up
3.4 = Starter
4.4 = All - Pro
                                       
  Rob Dorrough Penn State Average Rating 2.7  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Marginal Undesirable Undesirable Poor Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Undesirable 1.5  
  Scout 2 Marginal Marginal Marginal Excellent Marginal Excellent Marginal Good 3.8  
  Scout 3 Good Undesirable Poor Good Marginal Excellent Undesirable Undesirable 2.7  
  Scout 4 Good Marginal Poor Excellent Poor Excellent Undesirable Undesirable 2.8  
     
  Aove Average speed for his position He catches sometimes  
  A little slow off the ball He could play 3 games straight and not sweat  
  Not very good on making his cuts He doesn't think Often  
  Good Strength for his position It doesn't take much for him to loose concentration  
   
  Mel Says: Heading for free agency  
     
                                       
  Tarvaris Jackson Arizona State Average Rating 2.63  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Poor Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Undesirable 1.3  
  Scout 2 Marginal Marginal Marginal Marginal Marginal Excellent Good Excellent 3.7  
  Scout 3 Marginal Undesirable Undesirable Marginal Poor Excellent Marginal Good 2.7  
  Scout 4 Good Undesirable Undesirable Good Undesirable Good Undesirable Excellent 2.8  
     
  Average Speed for his position He catches sometimes  
  They used the minute hand to time him in the 40. Great Endurance keeps him going all day  
  Falling down is his answer to making cuts You don't want him thinking much!  
  Average Strength for his position Good Discipline for his position  
   
  Mel Says: Heading for free agency  
     
                                       
  Matt Michael San Diego Average Rating 2.48  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Good Undesirable Undesirable 1.1  
  Scout 2 Marginal Excellent Marginal Marginal Marginal Excellent Good Good 3.7  
  Scout 3 Marginal Good Undesirable Poor Marginal Excellent Marginal Undesirable 2.9  
  Scout 4 Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Excellent Undesirable Poor 2.2  
     
  A little on the slow side He catches sometimes  
  Average Quickness for his position Great Endurance keeps him going all day  
  Not very good on making his cuts You don't want him thinking much!  
  He can't lift much, but at least he can try It doesn't take much for him to loose concentration  
   
  Mel Says: Heading for free agency  
     
                                       
  Gerald Moss Nebraska Average Rating 2.45  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Good Undesirable Undesirable 1.1  
  Scout 2 Marginal Good Good Poor Marginal Excellent Poor Good 3.3  
  Scout 3 Marginal Marginal Good Undesirable Marginal Excellent Undesirable Marginal 2.8  
  Scout 4 Good Poor Poor Undesirable Marginal Excellent Undesirable Marginal 2.6  
     
  Average Speed for his position With some work he might actually hold onto the ball  
  With a little work he may be average. Great Endurance keeps him going all day  
  Average Agility for his position He doesn't think Often  
  He is better suited for lifting clipboards Average Discipline for his position  
   
  Mel Says: Heading for free agency  
     
                                       
  Johnny Nguyen Texas Average Rating 3.73  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Good Marginal Undesirable Poor Marginal Excellent Undesirable Excellent 2.9  
  Scout 2 Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent Poor Excellent 4.5  
  Scout 3 Excellent Good Marginal Good Excellent Excellent Undesirable Excellent 3.8  
  Scout 4 Good Good Marginal Good Excellent Excellent Undesirable Good 3.7  
     
  Watch him fly! Hands of glue  
  Good Quickness for his position He could play 3 games straight and not sweat  
  Average Agility for his position He doesn't think Often  
  Good Strength for his position He will be where you need him!  
   
  Mel Says: Late 4th or early 5th is where this guy should go.  I wouldn't pull the plug sooner or expect big things from him!  
     
                                       
  John Pieh Ohio State Average Rating 3.28  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Poor Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Undesirable 1.3  
  Scout 2 Excellent Marginal Excellent Marginal Excellent Excellent Excellent Good 4.4  
  Scout 3 Good Poor Good Marginal Excellent Excellent Good Marginal 3.8  
  Scout 4 Good Undesirable Marginal Good Good Excellent Marginal Good 3.6  
     
  Good Speed for his position Good Hands for his position  
  A little slow off the ball He could play 3 games straight and not sweat  
  Average Agility for his position Average Intelligence for his position  
  Average Strength for his position Average Discipline for his position  
   
  Mel Says: Late 4th or early 5th is where this guy should go.  I wouldn't pull the plug sooner or expect big things from him!  
     
                                       
  Darren Taylor Oregon Average Rating 3.8  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Good Undesirable Undesirable Marginal Poor Excellent Poor Good 2.6  
  Scout 2 Excellent Good Good Good Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent 4.6  
  Scout 3 Excellent Marginal Marginal Poor Excellent Excellent Excellent Good 3.9  
  Scout 4 Excellent Marginal Poor Good Excellent Excellent Marginal Excellent 4.1  
     
  They don't get much faster than this Good Hands for his position  
  Average Quickness for his position He could play 3 games straight and not sweat  
  Maybe he can improve Good Intelligence for his position  
  Average Strength for his position He will be where you need him!  
   
  Mel Says: Maybe with a lot of Work this guy could be a starter some day, but he has a lot of downsides to improve on, Draft him in the 4th.  
     
                                       
  Derek Watson Hawaii Average Rating 2.45  
  Overall Rating  
  Speed Acceleration Agility Strength Hands Endurance Intelligence Discipline  
  Scout 1 Good Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Poor 1.7  
  Scout 2 Excellent Poor Marginal Marginal Marginal Excellent Marginal Excellent 3.6  
  Scout 3 Good Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Marginal 1.9  
  Scout 4 Good Undesirable Undesirable Poor Undesirable Excellent Undesirable Excellent 2.6  
     
  Good Speed for his position You Don't want this guy hold the ball much  
  They used the minute hand to time him in the 40. He could play 3 games straight and not sweat  
  Falling down is his answer to making cuts He doesn't think Often  
  He can't lift much, but at least he can try Good Discipline for his position  
   
  Mel Says: Heading for free agency